New York City Pizza (Heritage Plaza)

New York City Pizza has been a Hilton Head Island Tradition since 1996. We are located on the North and South End of Hilton Head Island, as well as in Bluffton and Charleston, SC. We are proud to have won Best Pizza in Bluffton in 2011, Best New Restaurant on Hilton Head Island (Our North End Location) in 2012 and Best Pizza on Hilton Head Island for 2013. If you have never tried us before, ask a local and they will tell you that we are the local's favorite!